NEW RESEARCH RESULTS FOR

DR34

 

Three groups of people can be distinguished in this image: The people on the right side, the members of government at the center and the parliamentarians on the left. The latter look upwards and hold their hats expecting to catch the falling coins and rewards. It is interesting that neither the coins nor the hand of the king are visible. The lines suggest that his hand with the purse was covered subsequently with the armrest to make the "gifts" under the chair appear more visible.

 

The creation date and the proposed allocation to La Caricature are occasionally questioned. It is certain that the December 15, 1831 edition of La Caricature contained only the lithographs „Mr. Croupion“ by Audibert / Delaporte and "Précautions inutiles" by Wattier / Philipon - but not "Gargantua". Also on December 16 there were two lithographs - but not "Gargantua" - which could indicate that this print was planned from the outset as a separate product. Daumier's first lithograph for La Caricature was actually published only on February 9, 1832 - nearly two months later (see DR40).

 

In the literature, this lithograph is seen as a prime example of Daumier’s fearless attitude towards the king and the corrupt July-monarchy. The details of his arrest, trial, conviction, etc are considered as facts and are repeated in each new text on this subject. But it seems that no author has ever researched and cited the primary sources, ie, the Daumier case file.

 

Daumier as author, Delaporte as printer and Aubert as print dealer were standing before the circuit court in Paris on February 22, 1832 (and not on February 23, as is always indicated). They were accused of incitement to hatred and contempt of the government, the head of state, and the king. The Gazette des tribunaux of February 23, 1832 reported briefly on the last page that Delaporte and Aubert rejected any responsibility; Daumier asserted to have had no evil intentions and ascribed everything to his youthful foolishness: his Gargantua being not even a caricature of the king, but the general symbol of corruption. The very fact that he is just dressed like all other people is proof of this. The jury did not accept this justification and declared all three defendants guilty. Thereafter, the court sentenced them each to 6 months in prison and fines of 500 francs. The court dealt on the same day with the lithograph DR32. The indictment was identical, but in this case the jury declared the accused as innocent. An appeal would have been futile because the decision of the jury could not be changed, only procedural flaws could possibly result in a new trial. On February 28, 1832 Daumier, Aubert and Delaporte submitted a request for clemency, which the very devoted king might benevolently and positively grant to his humble and obedient servants, according to the tenor of the letter:

 

«Sire,
Trois hommes qui n'ont jamais été animés contre vous d'aucun sentiment de haine viennent d'être condamnés à six mois de prison pour une caricature dans laquelle le jury a crû voir une offense à votre auguste personne.
L'artiste, jeune homme de vingt trois ans, n'avait mis aucune importance à un dessin qui lui semblait inoffensif; l'imprimeur a cru sa responsabilité à couvert par la signature du dessin, par la formalité du dépôt et par le nom de l'éditeur, celui-ci, père de famille et marchand, n'a pas pensé qu'il pût être compromis par une caricature, ou il ne voyait rien qui lui parût personnel à votre majesté.
Sire, ils s'adressent à vous pour les sauver d'une captivité qu'ils n'ont pas méritée par leurs intentions, et qui les plongerait eux et leurs familles dans une ruine et un malheur irréparable.
Plein d'espoir en votre générosité, ils attendent, Sire, l'arrêt que vous allez prononcer.
Vos très humbles et très obéissants serviteurs»
 Aubert, Delaporte et Daumier
 

 

Ironically, it was in his debut for La Caricature (DR40) that Daumier ridiculed the submissive elite. The caption reads: „très humbles, très soumis, très obéissans ...“. The appeal for clemency filed as BB/21/373/4172/S8 in the National Archives resulted in May 1832 with an amnesty for Aubert and Delaporte; Daumier however was imprisoned. He was allowed to spend the period from November 10, 1832 to February 22, 1833 in the Psychiatric Hospital "Chaillot" with Dr. Scipion Pinel. This was however neither due to his mental state, nor was he a special case. Already during the restoration an insightful political prisoner was occasionally allowed to apply for transfer to a hospital.

 

By the way, it should be noted that a dozen lawsuits against La Caricature, Le Charivari and their employees can not always be regarded as harassment or even as persecution by the government. Newspapers like La Tribune, Le National, even the legalistic La Gazette de France were seized countless times and their editors punished. Satire, however, particularly in the form of ambiguous lithographs was not so easy to pin down.

 

 

Dr. Scipion Pinel (1795-1859) was a psychiatrist and son of the famous physician Dr. Philippe Pinel (1745-1826), who particularly advocated humane and scientifically oriented psychiatry. His academic authority and his successful treatments with prisoners resulted in the release of mentally ill people from their chains. His son Scipion was known for the court-approved counseling and treatment of prisoners that were soon to be released. He succeeded in this "disguise" to grant protection to several opponents or to facilitate their conditions of detention.